View source for MotiveValidator:Principles

[[File:MV_manual_figures2.png|thumb|right|600px| Scheme of the '''validation procedure''' for an input motif. In this example a beta-D-galactose ('''GAL''') is inspected for the completenes, chirality issues and naming issues. ON the right a typical validation results are available.]]

=Validation procedure=
Within the '''MotiveValidator''' environment, the term ''validation'' refers to the process of determining whether a molecule is structurally complete and correctly annotated. This means checking if the topology and chirality of each validated molecule correspond to those of the model with the same annotation (3-letter code) as the validated molecule.

'''MotiveValidator''' implements the ''validation of annotation'' approach, which consists of several steps. First, for each molecule under investigation, the ''input motif'' is extracted from the input. At the same time, the appropriate ''model'' is retrieved from wwPDB CCD. Then, the ''validated molecule'' (or ''validated motif'') is identified as the subset of atoms common in the ''model'' and the ''input motif''. Subsequently, the ''validated molecule'' is compared against the ''model'', atom by atom. All the validation analyses in '''MotiveValidator''' are based on this comparison of atom properties (presence, chirality, element symbol, PDB name, etc.). Other unusual aspects encountered during validation are reported as processing warnings (e.g., which conformer was validated if several conformers were present).

=Validation analyses=
The validation analyses performed by '''MotiveValidator''' cover all main issues which have been observed in the topology (2D structure) and geometry (3D structure) of ligands and non-standard residues. These validation analyses, along with their respective results, can be classified into three categories, namely ''Completeness'', ''Chirality'' and ''Advanced'' analyses.

The ''Completeness'' analyses attempt to find which atoms are missing, whether these atoms are part of rings, or the structure is degenerate, i.e., the molecule contains very severe errors. These may refer to residues overlapping in the 3D space, or atoms which are disconnected from the rest of the structure.

The ''Chirality'' analyses are performed only on complete structures, and aim to evaluate the chirality of each atom in the validated molecule. We distinguish between several types of chirality errors: on carbon atoms (C chirality), on metal atoms (Metal chirality), on atoms with 4 substituents in one plane (Planar chirality), on atoms connected to at least one substituent by a bond of higher order (High order chirality), and the remaining chirality issues (Other chirality).

The ''Advanced'' analyses are focused on issues which are not real chemical problems, but which can complicate further processing and exploration of data, and thus should be noted. The Substitution analysis reports the replacement of some atom by an atom of a different chemical element. The Foreign atom analysis detects atoms which originate from the neighborhood of the validated molecule (i.e., having different PDB residue ID than the majority of the validated molecule), and generally marks sites of inter-molecular linkage. The Different naming analysis identifies atoms whose name in PDB format is different than the standard convention for the validated molecule. The Zero RMSD analysis reports molecules whose structure is identical (root mean square deviation = 0 Å) to the model from wwPDB CCD. The Alternate conformations analysis informs about the occurrence of alternate conformations in the validated PDB entry.

=Validation results=
Each molecule is evaluated depending on how it fares during the validation analyses described above. If no issues are found during the validation analyses, the molecule is marked as having ''complete structure and correct chirality''. Validated molecules exhibiting an error in at least one of the ''Completeness'' analyses are denoted as ''incomplete'', whereas the remaining molecules are reported as ''complete''. If no issues are detected during the ''Chirality'' analyses, the validated molecule is marked as having ''Correct chirality'', whereas the remaining molecules are marked as having ''Wrong chirality''. When issues are found during an ''Advanced'' analysis, a warning is reported: Substitution, Foreign atom, Different naming, Zero RMSD or Alternate conformations. Each type of issue encountered during validation has a specific color code. 

Some types of chirality errors do not constitute real issues, but are artifacts of the automated chirality determination procedure. Specifically, an error in planar chirality may just mean that the chiral atom is situated slightly above or below the plane compared to its equivalent in the model from wwPDB CCD. Further, an error in high order chirality often marks the involvement of phosphate O atoms in salt or ester formation, or merely a different PDB format identification of phosphate O atoms of the validated molecule compared to the model. Therefore, if the validated molecule is found to have planar or high order chirality errors, but no other type of chirality issues, the molecule is marked as having ''Correct chirality (tolerant)''.

While the results of the ''Advanced'' analyses have no bearing over the chemical soundness of the validated molecules, they indicate that further, especially automated processing of these structures can be very problematic. Comparison between the structures of molecules with the same annotation (3-letter code) from different PDB entries might even be impossible in the presence of a substitution, as the corresponding atoms have different chemical elements. PDB atom names cannot be used straightforwardly, since even element symbols can differ and atoms can be formally included in neighboring residues.

=Validation reports=
For each '''MotiveValidator''' job, the molecules deemed for validation are detected and validated. The result is systematically organized into reports:

* Summary of validation results for all validated molecules.
* Detailed validation report for a set of molecules with particular molecule identifiers.
* Detailed validation report for individual validated molecule.